Most critics are won over, and the praise clusters on the talk. Reviews describe the dialogue between Ethan Hawke and Julie Delpy as witty, perceptive and lifelike, and several credit Richard Linklater with making a single night of wandering Vienna feel like a story rather than an exercise. The chemistry of the two leads comes up in nearly every notice, and most treat the film’s refusal to tie things up neatly as a strength rather than an evasion.
Reservations are few and mild, and the spread is narrow. The one mixed notice is Variety, where Todd McCarthy finds the premise appealing but the constant conversation and repeated settings wearing, and rates Delpy’s performance well above Hawke’s. The Los Angeles Times and The Independent are warmer but call the film minor or risky, enjoying the talk without being swept away. The most recent reviews are among the warmest, which suggests its standing has risen since 1995.
