Most critics regard this as one of Kubrick’s most fully achieved films. The praise clusters on two things: the decision to treat nuclear deterrence as black comedy rather than earnest thriller, and Peter Sellers’ three performances. Reviewers from the first release onward describe the same effect, laughter turning to dread as the plot follows its premise to the end, and those who return to it on re-release find it undated. George C. Scott and the War Room scenes also draw repeated mention.
Dissent is narrow. Fourteen of fifteen reviews are positive, and the lone negative notice comes from The New York Times, which in 1964 called the premise a reckless science-fiction fabrication and objected to the film’s implied fatalism about the bomb, while still crediting the screenplay and performances. Sight and Sound is cooler than the rest, calling the film tough and uncompromising rather than delightful. Beyond that, reservations barely register.
