Most critics respond favourably to Eyes Wide Shut, with praise clustering around Kubrick’s eerie, dreamlike direction and his treatment of marriage, jealousy and sexual fantasy. The more appreciative reviews find its deliberate pace hypnotic, its encounters unsettling and its domestic intimacy more affecting than its elaborate sexual spectacle. Cruise’s performance draws praise for bringing humanity to the psychological probing, while Kidman and the supporting cast also receive favourable notice.
The reservations concern drawn-out scenes, emotional distance and sexual imagery that some critics find tame or dated. The spread is wide: Total Film finds the pace tedious and the eroticism ineffective, though it admires the opening party’s decadent languour. Film Comment directly disputes the charge of dullness and highlights humour that other readings overlook. The Independent takes a mixed position, finding the marital intimacy persuasive but the dialogue and dramatic stakes unconvincing.
