All thirteen reviews are positive, and the praise gathers in the same places. Most critics remark on the warmth and humour, which they find unusual for Bergman, and call this the most accessible of his films. The portrayal of childhood is the achievement named most often, along with the reading of the film as a summing-up of his lifelong concerns with family, faith and imagination. Sven Nykvist’s photography, the production design and the ensemble acting, the children in particular, are singled out repeatedly, as is the opening Christmas sequence.
The spread is narrow and the reservations are mild. The New Yorker enjoys the film enormously but finds it straining for greatness and less alive than Bergman’s earlier work. Collider is warm but cooler than most, reserving its praise for the bishop as a complex antagonist. Several critics note the darkness under the warmth: The Guardian finds the depiction of abuse disturbing, and The Times describes a battle of wills with a memorable jump scare.
