Mrs. Doubtfire (1993)

The reviewer notes that despite some uncalled-for sentimentality in the second half, the film remains a laugh riot thanks to Robin Williams' performance as the nanny in disguise.

This is family entertainment par excellence, with Robin Williams delivering one of his best performances as the disguised father. Director Chris Columbus is praised for controlling Williams' exuberance while highlighting strong set pieces like the quick-change restaurant scene.

Finds it overly sappy and too long but provides a slick showcase for Williams' shtick with broad family appeal, mixing comedy and messages about family.

The critic describes the film as sitcom-like with laboured farcical interludes and a mushy post-feminist sensibility. Williams' performance as the nanny is singled out as the source of its fun despite the flaws.

Notes the film's commercial success due to Williams but laments his shift from anarchic comedy to warm and cuddly roles, calling it a safe and sane but unadventurous entertainment.

The critic finds Mrs Doubtfire a lightweight creation despite the brilliant mimicry of the disguise, comparing it unfavorably to Tootsie for lacking dramatic mileage in the central character. Other elements like the wife and rival are sharper, and the film is seen as Hollywood liberalism that avoids easy resolutions.

The critic finds the film not as amusing as the premise, with long stretches that drag, comparing it unfavorably to Tootsie as having sitcom values and depth.

The critic calls the film a warm, uplifting holiday comedy that should be a major hit, blending broad slapstick with pointed drama about a family's painful separation. Robin Williams delivers a standout dual performance as the father and the nanny, showing both his hyperkinetic humor and the pain beneath it, with strong support from the cast and director Chris Columbus.

Praises Robin Williams' genius for details and improvisation but criticizes the film for spending too much time making nice and not enough making sense, with a simple-minded story.

The critic praises Robin Williams' wonderful performance in the role, blending comedy and genuine emotion without cynicism. The film handles the pain of divorce with farce, giving it relevance beyond simple enjoyment.