The reviews are unanimous in the film’s favour: all twenty-four are positive, and the praise gathers around two things. The first is Inde Navarrette, whose turn as the possessed Nikki is named in almost every notice as the reason to see it, described as fearless, unsettling and star-making. The second is Curry Barker’s handling of an old premise, the wish for love that goes wrong, which most critics find freshened by dark comedy, well-timed shocks, sparing gore and careful sound design.
The spread is narrow, running from solid approval to raves. Where critics hold back, it is on the ideas rather than the craft. Vulture thinks the premise is reduced to genre clichés and says little about desire; RogerEbert.com finds the lack of a female perspective limits the film’s depth; Sight and Sound notes pacing lapses and one cartoonish murder scene. A few mention a sagging second act. Digital Spy sits furthest out, with full marks.
I
IndieWire
13 May 2026 · Christian Zilko
90*
The review praises Barker's direction of a simple 'be careful what you wish for' premise that exceeds expectations by making viewers more afraid to be the perpetrator than the victim. It positions the film as one of 2026's best horror movies.
Read the full review →A
The AV Club
13 May 2026 · A- · Monica Castillo
90
Barker turns the 'be careful what you wish for' trope into a blistering horror with escalating tension, carnage, and unease from the start. It praises Navarrette's wild, committed performance (channeling Possession) and the effective cinematography and editing.
Read the full review →H
The Hollywood Reporter
11 May 2026 · Frank Scheck
90*
The critic praises the film for freshening up the well-worn 'Monkey's Paw' horror formula with a skillful mix of dread, jump scares, and dark comedy, marking an instant breakout for director-writer Curry Barker. The lead performances are highlighted, especially Inde Navarrette's intense and frightening turn as the possessed love interest.
Read the full review →E
Empire
15 May 2026 · Lou Thomas
85*
The critic finds Barker's horror a fresh and exhilarating twist on the 'be careful what you wish for' trope, praising its blackly funny and gory take on unhealthy infatuations. Navarrette's performance as the increasingly unhinged Nikki is singled out as sensational, with her outlandish actions providing many of the film's finest moments.
Read the full review →L
Little White Lies
13 May 2026 · 4/4/4 · Emma Kiely
80
The critic finds it a truly effective psychological horror that marks the theatrical debut of a singular horror vision. She singles out the lead performances, especially Inde Navarrette as Nikki, along with the director’s moody colour grading, grip on scare timings and sparing but effective use of gore.
Read the full review →R
Radio Times
4 June 2026 · ★★★★ · Patrick Cremona
80
The film is praised as a clever, low-budget horror that intelligently explores consent themes with innovative direction and a standout gory scare. It is sincere, fresh and darkly funny, raising questions about Barker's potential with bigger resources.
Read the full review →S
Screen Daily
12 May 2026 · festival review
80*
Barker's horror is an astute and entertainingly schlocky study of romantic co-dependency and patriarchal entitlement that subverts familiar wish-fulfillment tropes. Johnston and Navarrette impress in the central romance-gone-wrong dynamic.
Read the full review →G
The Guardian
6 September 2025 · festival review
80*
The critic praises this debut feature from YouTuber-turned-filmmaker Curry Barker as a slick, effective upgrade from his viral shorts, delivering a cannily handled monkey's-paw premise about a wish for love gone wrong. They single out the lead performance by Inde Navarrette for its chilling transformation and the film's visceral, gory shocks and sound design.
Read the full review →T
Time Out
12 March 2026 · ★★★★ · Dan Jolin
80
The critic finds the film an entertainingly nasty twist on romcom conventions that descends into disturbing psycho-horror. Navarrette's bold performance as the possessed love interest stands out amid some visual clichés.
Read the full review →V
Variety
14 May 2026 · Guy Lodge
80*
The critic finds the film a clever and creepy take on the monkey's paw trope applied to modern relationships, praising its unnerving execution and standout performance by Inde Navarrette. They highlight the director's skillful blend of horror and commentary on codependency.
Read the full review →S
Slant Magazine
11 May 2026 · Marshall Shaffer
75*
The critic praises Barker's skill at lingering in awkward, ambiguous conversations to build tension and discomfort, along with the confident execution of chilling set pieces and gory sequences. The film is positioned as a cautionary tale about the perils of wishing for one-sided love rather than genuine connection.
Read the full review →L
Los Angeles Times
15 May 2026 · Katie Walsh
70*
The critic finds the film an effective horror take on obsessive love, praising Navarrette's instantly classic performance as the terrifying Nikki and Barker's command of style and pace. The premise is familiar but executed with dread and violence that elevates it.
Read the full review →R
RogerEbert.com
15 May 2026 · Katie Rife
70*
The film channels 2020s cultural anxieties into a cruel, unsettling horror morality tale with grotesque imagery and destabilizing rhythm. Navarrette's powerhouse performance is highlighted, though the lack of a female perspective limits its thematic depth.
Read the full review →S
Sight and Sound
7 May 2026
70*
The film blends genres effectively, mixing bloody violence with awkward humour and visceral horror through strong performances, especially Inde Navarrette's dual-natured Nikki. It holds a troubling mirror to male fears and desires but has some flaws in subtlety, pacing and one cartoonish murder scene.
Read the full review →The film has a clever premise about obsessive love as a curse but reduces intriguing ideas to genre clichés and does little with deeper notions of desire. It praises Navarrette's performance for making the character's unpredictability believable and the claustrophobic focus on the central relationship.
Read the full review →D
Digital Spy
15 May 2026 · ★★★★★ · Ian Sandwell
100
The critic calls it one of the year's best films overall and a standout horror, highlighting its unpredictable twisted turns, strong lead performances especially Inde Navarrette's star-making turn, and effective direction that balances discomfort, scares, and dark humor.
Read the full review →E
Eye for Film
23 May 2026 · festival review · Andrew Robertson
90*
The critic calls it a well-crafted efficient horror thriller, an incredible version of an old story, indicator of talent and an absolute treat. Praises performances, especially Navarrette, and production design.
Read the full review →N
NME
15 May 2026 · Alex Flood
90*
The critic calls it the freshest and most terrifying horror film of the year so far. They single out Inde Navarrette’s fearless, unsettling performance as Nikki (transformed into an obsessive, nightmarish figure) for particular praise, alongside Barker’s sharp dialogue, sparse lighting, and innovative sound design that creates effective jump-scares.
Read the full review →/
/Film
14 April 2026 · 8.5/10 · BJ Colangelo
85
The critic describes the film as a confident crowd-pleaser that smartly avoids sympathy for its entitled protagonist. They single out Inde Navarrette's astonishing, star-making performance as the monstrous femme for particular praise.
Read the full review →P
Polygon
12 May 2026 · Jesse Hassenger
85*
The critic praises the film as an innovative, secular take on possession horror that avoids typical Exorcist ripoffs by framing it as a monkey's-paw wish story. They single out Inde Navarrette's bravura performance as the possessed character for creating a mix of fear and pity.
Read the full review →C
Collider
28 May 2026 · 8/10 · Hannah Hunt
80
The critic highlights the exploration of emotional entitlement and 'nice guy' dangers, excellent performances especially Navarrette's, strong direction, sound design, and pacing. It's emotionally devastating psychological horror.
Read the full review →D
Deadline
15 May 2026 · Glenn Garner
80*
The critic praises Curry Barker's sophomore feature as a chilling horror breakout that establishes his style, while highlighting Inde Navarrette's performance as solidifying her status as a scream queen in the making. Navarrette's chilling, unpredictable portrayal of the possessed Nikki—with its demonic mood swings and creepy mannerisms—is singled out for praise as terrifying and exhilarating.
Read the full review →H
HeyUGuys
11 May 2026 · ★★★★ · Linda Marric
80
The critic praises the fresh take on the premise, focusing on desire and possession, with standout performances by Navarrette and Johnston, and emotional specificity in the horror. Minor issues with pacing in the second act.
Read the full review →P
The Playlist
12 May 2026 · B+/A- · Carlos Aguilar
70*
The critic calls it a gruesome, darkly funny two-hander about obsession, control, and the horror of getting exactly what you asked for. They single out the lead performances for turning toxic love into a grotesque nightmare and for sharp commentary on poisonous relationships.
Read the full review →Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate