Most critics come down in favour of the Coens’ second film, and the praise clusters on the writing. Reviewers admire the invention of the dialogue, the audacious opening stretch before the credits, and the seedy, mythical Arizona the brothers build and fill with no-hopers. Cage and Hunter are praised, and Carter Burwell’s score and Barry Sonnenfeld’s camerawork are singled out. Several count it among the Coens’ warmest work.
The spread is wide, and the reservations are about pace and structure rather than craft. Variety finds the loosely built story does not always hold together; RogerEbert.com finds the dialogue over-mannered and the film short of velocity. The Los Angeles Times goes further, calling it technically adept but boring and condescending towards its trailer-park characters, and Eye for Film sees no serviceable plot at all. The coolest notices date from 1987; those written since are almost uniformly warm.
