Most critics take Sisu on its own terms and enjoy it there: a Finnish gold miner against a Nazi platoon, told in comic-book chapters with a spaghetti-western spine, and dispatched with escalating, inventive gore. The praise clusters on two things. One is the violence itself, which reviewers repeatedly find imaginative rather than merely plentiful, likened more than once to a live-action cartoon. The other is Jorma Tommila, whose stony, near-silent lead performance is credited with holding the mayhem together. Jalmari Helander’s confidence and pacing draw approval too.
The reservations are consistent but mild: the premise is one note, the killing grows repetitive, and several reviews call it fun that will not linger. The spread is narrow, most landing between good and very good. The clear dissenter is The New York Times, which finds the carnage tame and short on wit, a view almost nobody else shares. IndieWire and Time Out sit in the middle, enjoying the set pieces while noting filler between them.
