With only 5 reviews in so far, the consensus is positive, with praise centred on the mother-daughter relationship, the mixture of wit and feeling, and the performances of Shirley MacLaine and Jack Nicholson. The reviews value the sharply observed family tensions and the humour that keeps them from becoming oppressive. Reservations concern construction rather than performances: Variety finds the decades-spanning structure disjointed and the film weaker when its leads are absent. Time Out offers the strongest reservations, arguing that the later emotional intensity, though powerfully acted, unbalances what begins as an amusing family comedy.
The film masterfully balances comedy and tragedy in a way that feels true to life. Ebert singles out Debra Winger's performance as outstanding and natural.
Read the full review →