Most critics admire it, and the praise gathers in the same places: Irène Jacob’s performance as both women, Zbigniew Preisner’s score, and the golden, drifting camerawork. The reviews agree that Kieślowski has no interest in explaining the connection between his two heroines, and most take that as the point. For them this is a film about chance and parallel lives that works through image and music rather than plot, and several describe the effect as a trance or a dream.
The dissent is sharp rather than wide, and it dates. The three negative reviews all come from the 1991 release: the Los Angeles Times finds a stylish but hollow puzzle closer to a perfume advertisement than cinema, Variety says the French half loses momentum after a strong Polish opening, and The New York Times finds the symbolism opaque and of little urgency. Later reassessments are far warmer, though even admirers such as The Times concede it does not give up its secrets easily.
