Most critics like it, with reservations that cluster in the same place. The praise goes to the cast, with Andrew Garfield, Claire Foy and Coughlan named repeatedly, and to the production design, which several reviews find hand-made and faithful to the look of the books. Simon Farnaby’s screenplay is credited with giving a plotless source a heart and some gentle wit, and most reviews agree the modern updates are handled sensibly.
The reservations are about sweetness and stakes: the film is called twee more than once, the plot is said to meander, and comparisons to Paddington and to Farnaby’s other adaptations do it no favours. The spread is wide. The Hollywood Reporter finds it exhausting for anyone but the youngest viewers, and The Times calls the screenplay a muddle of skits; Variety finds it pleasant but cautious and not funny enough. Everyone else lands somewhere between decent and good.
