Most critics like Wicker, and the praise gathers almost entirely around its two leads. Olivia Colman’s fisherwoman and Alexander Skarsgård’s wicker husband are described as weird, warm and oddly believable, with Skarsgård’s work inside the costume singled out again and again. The practical effects and the expressive design of the husband draw repeated admiration, and several reviews find the central romance touching beneath the bawdy humour.
The reservations are about shape and purpose. Several critics call the fable overstuffed or underdeveloped, with an ending that runs long and a second-act moral turn that fails to convince. The spread is wide, with two reviews firmly negative. The Guardian finds the romance too thin to earn any emotional investment, despite Colman’s commitment, and The Wrap calls the whole thing wearisome, stiff and predictable, reserving its praise for Peter Dinklage. Even admirers concede the premise never quite finds a larger point.
