Every review of Working Girl is positive, and the praise gathers around Melanie Griffith. Critics describe her Tess McGill as radiant, scrappy and tenacious, and most agree her performance carries the film. Mike Nichols’s assured direction and a witty screenplay attentive to class come next, then the supporting cast, with Joan Cusack singled out repeatedly and Sigourney Weaver admired as the boss. Several reviews call it a Cinderella story or urban fairy tale and mean it kindly.
The spread is narrow, from good to very good, and the reservations are about politics rather than craft. Little White Lies sets the film against 9 to 5 and finds it has traded sisterhood for individual advancement, uneasy that Tess rises by tearing down another woman. Eye for Film calls it darker than its reputation, a bleak political statement dressed up as romance. Roger Ebert, more approving, notes how much of the plotting runs as a thriller. Nobody disputes that it is fun.
