The reviews split down the middle, four warm and four cold, with nobody in between. Where critics agree is on the cast. Bryan Cranston and Jane Kaczmarek are singled out in nearly every review, by admirers and detractors alike, and Cranston’s physical comedy earns credit even from those who dislike the series. The admiring reviews find it funny in the old manner and are pleased that returning creator Linwood Boomer offers more than a nostalgic epilogue.
The doubters ask why it exists at all. Several find the humour laboured and the four-episode run closer to a reunion special than a series. Both The Telegraph and The Hollywood Reporter object to the weight placed on Malcolm’s childhood trauma, the first likening the result to a therapy session, the second finding it uncomfortable rather than moving. Even supporters concede the brief run leaves the large family underserved. The spread is wide: this is a revival critics either take to or resent.
