The reviews lean strongly positive and have done since the first festival showings. Most critics agree it is funny, and that the comedy comes from the talk: arguments about work, sex and pop culture between two clerks stuck behind a counter for a day. The praise clusters on Kevin Smith’s script, on the pairing of the leads, and on how much he gets from a black-and-white film shot in one New Jersey shop on next to nothing. Several notice a sweetness under the rudeness.
The reservations are about the same things. A few find it crude and built as a string of sketches rather than a story; The AV Club goes furthest, calling it an assemblage of vignettes with dubious sexual politics and little substance beyond its DIY roots. The spread is otherwise narrow. The warmest notices are the earliest; later pieces run cooler, and some, The Wrap among them, praise it as much for what it launched as for what it is.
