Most critics come down in favour, seven of twelve, and the praise gathers in one place: the mountain footage. The stunt work and the climbing sequences filmed at altitude are what the reviews remember, and Renny Harlin’s staging of the set-pieces is credited more than once as the best work of his career. The opening scene draws admiration, and several critics treat the film as the picture that put Stallone back on his feet.
The reservations sit almost entirely with the script. Clichéd dialogue, a weak villain and a plot that strains belief once the action stops turn up in favourable and unfavourable reviews alike. The spread is wide, from warm approval to outright dismissal. The New Yorker finds the early excitement giving way to cheapness and nonsense, the Los Angeles Times objects to the sadistic violence, and both Time Out and The Independent argue the vertical drama never produces vertigo. Later reappraisals are warmer than some notices from 1993.
