Most critics like Delicatessen, and seven of the ten reviews are positive. The praise clusters on the look of the thing: the sets, the effects and the rhythmically edited set pieces get named again and again, along with the crowd of grotesque tenants above the butcher’s shop. Reviewers keep reaching for Gilliam and Lynch as points of comparison, and most mean it kindly. The balance of farce and horror, with a childlike centre under the cannibalism, is what wins them over.
The reservations cluster on originality and warmth. Several critics note how much the film owes to Brazil and find the whimsy sometimes overdone. The spread is wide: two reviews are negative. The AV Club calls it a stylistically sloppy early effort from Jeunet and Caro, while Slant finds it unfunny and short of compassion for its characters, who become props in a chase. The New York Times sits in the middle, finding it clever but not radically new.
