Jean-Pierre Jeunet and Marc Caro make cannibalism surprisingly cheerful in this nimble, crowded black comedy. The supporting eccentrics can become tiresome, but the precise slapstick and Dominique Pinon’s sweetness keep the nastiness funny.
Delicatessen is a funny, carefully made black comedy that occasionally fusses too much over its own oddness. Jean-Pierre Jeunet and Marc Caro put an ex-clown to work above a butcher’s shop in a post-apocalyptic future, then let him fall for the butcher’s daughter. Cannibalism is part of everyday life here, which gives even the prospect of settling down an unpleasant implication. The directors want us to enjoy the absurdity without forgetting what makes the place dangerous.
Dominique Pinon gives Louison the innocence the film needs if its cruelty is to remain bearable. A former clown could easily become an excuse for a performance full of appealing little tricks; Pinon’s physical comedy feels like a way this man gets through the day. Marie-Laure Dougnac’s Julie gives the romance enough tenderness to matter amid the grotesque behaviour. Jean-Claude Dreyfus, as Clapet, supplies a threat sufficiently blunt that the film can afford all those peculiar people around him.
Production designers Miljen ‘Kreka’ Kljaković and Caro make the butcher’s shop and its surroundings feel suited to the people who inhabit them. The crowded sets give the eye things to investigate while the actors get on with being peculiar. Darius Khondji’s photography gives these spaces an oppressive, unreal presence. His images keep the suggestion of horror alive even when the performances are broad, so the grotesque faces never become entirely cosy.
The most persuasive display of control comes in the rhythmic montage. Editor Hervé Schneid links the images with such exact timing that the cutting becomes the joke, and each new addition has somewhere to land. We laughed because the sequence keeps making its pattern more ridiculous without losing the beat. Carlos D’Alessio’s music keeps the comedy light enough for the ugliness not to become wearying.
The screenplay, by Jeunet, Caro and Gilles Adrien, is less dependable when it asks us to enjoy another eccentric simply for being eccentric. Some of the supporting figures seem to have been given a peculiarity in place of a personality. The humour becomes laboured when a character has nothing to offer beyond the odd thing they do, and the romance has to compete for attention. There is enough invention to carry these passages, though we would gladly exchange a few flourishes for more time with Louison and Julie.
Black comedy can grow monotonous when every human weakness receives the same punishment. Jeunet and Caro avoid that trap often enough because they keep Louison sympathetic, helped considerably by Pinon’s performance. The cannibalism is ghastly, but the film takes pleasure in the clown’s physical humour as well as the surrounding depravity. That makes its blend of farce and horror more inviting than the premise suggests, without requiring us to find every resident endearing.
At 99 minutes, the film does not ask for more patience than its inventions can repay. We would happily spend another evening with Pinon’s Louison, even if several of his neighbours could use less encouragement. Choose it for the slapstick, provided cannibalism is something everyone present can agree to laugh about.