Most critics like it, and most of them like it for the same reasons. The reviews are warm about the first hour, the hostage-taking and the drive for Mexico, and about George Clooney, whose performance is picked out again and again as the film’s centre of gravity. Rodriguez’s inventive kills and the gruesome effects work draw praise, as do the dialogue and the energy of the thing. Several critics recommend going in knowing as little as possible.
The reservations cluster on the second half. Even admirers call the vampire mayhem uneven or juvenile, and the spread is wide. The Hollywood Reporter finds the horror-comedy overblown and revolting rather than substantial, and the Los Angeles Times admires the fight choreography while dismissing the conceit itself as road kill. The New Yorker calls the second half cheesy and derivative. The 1996 notices are the coolest; later reviews are fonder, treating the genre switch as the point.
