Most critics come down firmly in favour, and the praise gathers in the same place: the boot camp that fills the first half. R. Lee Ermey’s drill sergeant is singled out again and again, with Vincent D’Onofrio and Matthew Modine close behind. Several reviews also credit the two-part structure itself, arguing that the split between training and combat is what sets the film apart from other Vietnam pictures, and that its standing has grown over time.
The reservations cluster just as tightly, on the Vietnam half. RogerEbert.com finds the film shapeless once it leaves the barracks, and Empire finds Kubrick powerful in the camp but unengaged once the fighting starts. Time Out goes further, calling the direction cold and manipulative and the recruits hard to care about. The Hollywood Reporter stands alone in dismissing the whole thing as a didactic misfire. The spread is wide, from full marks to near contempt, but the dissenters are few.
