Most critics rate Husbands and Wives among Woody Allen’s strongest films, and several call it his best since Hannah and Her Sisters. The praise clusters on the ensemble acting, with Judy Davis singled out almost everywhere and Sydney Pollack close behind. The handheld, documentary-style camerawork is the other point of agreement: most reviews find its jerky, raw manner well suited to the characters’ confusion as their marriages come apart. The film itself is read as a study of mid-life panic and jealousy, brutal and funny at once.
The reservations are few and mostly about the same thing. Time Out thinks the handheld camera is occasionally overdone, and The Independent goes further, calling the pseudo-documentary style self-consciously amateurish and asking whether the film works as quiet self-justification given the parallels with Allen’s own life. The New Yorker also finds it uncomfortably personal. That is the only real dissent; the spread is narrow, with one mixed review and none negative.
