Most critics are won over. The reviews lean warmly positive, with nine of eleven in favour, and the praise clusters on the two leads: Kenneth Branagh and Emma Thompson as Benedick and Beatrice, whose sparring most find sharp and the film’s chief pleasure. Branagh’s direction is credited with making the play accessible and high-spirited, and the Tuscan villa setting, the starry ensemble and the cheerful pace come up again and again. Several single out Michael Keaton’s Dogberry and Denzel Washington’s Don Pedro.
The spread is wide. Two reviews reject the film outright. The New Yorker finds the lush visuals and forced cheer crowd out the play’s darker edges and wit, and complains of the slapstick, though it praises Washington’s restrained Don Pedro. The Independent calls the adaptation lacklustre and self-indulgent, and is unusual in faulting Thompson and Branagh themselves. Among the admirers, Variety thinks the images undistinguished given the setting, and Time Out finds the leads better at romance than comedy.
