Critics’ reviews

The Weight (2026)

15 reviews from 15 publications. Critics’ score 68: 8 positive, 5 mixed, 2 negative.

Back to our review of The Weight

68
Positive
8
Mixed
5
Negative
2

Most critics come away warm on The Weight, Padraic McKinley’s debut about prisoners hauling gold through the Oregon wilderness in the Depression. The praise gathers almost entirely around Ethan Hawke, whose stoic, near-wordless lead performance is singled out in nearly every review as the thing holding the film together. Beyond him, the reviews like the film’s 1970s throwback feel, the grubby, lived-in period detail and a handful of practical set pieces, the rope bridge crossing chief among them.

The reservations are about pace and script. Several critics find the middle stretches slack and the plotting too straightforward, with few surprises and thin supporting characters. The spread is wide: the film’s harshest notices, from The Hollywood Reporter and IndieWire, call it murky and underpowered, while later reviews from RogerEbert.com and The AV Club are among its most enthusiastic. The Los Angeles Times, otherwise admiring, wishes it had been braver in its final minutes.

RogerEbert.com
18 September 2026 · Matt Zoller Seitz
90*

The critic calls the film successful in every department as a prison movie, wilderness adventure, psychological thriller, and political fable about capital and labor. Hawke's performance is singled out as one of his best, anchoring the drama with minimalism and gravitas.

Read the full review →
Screen Daily
27 January 2026 · festival review
90*

Padraic McKinley’s confident debut is a hugely effective survivalist tale set in 1930s Oregon wilderness, with grizzled performances from Ethan Hawke and Russell Crowe. The critic highlights memorable set pieces and human stakes in this tense, character-driven adventure.

Read the full review →
The AV Club
15 September 2026 · B+ · Mitchell Beaupre
83

Ethan Hawke excels in this throwback '70s-style adventure about prisoners transporting gold through dangerous wilderness, with great performances and exciting set pieces. It highlights the director's care in world-building, strong character focus, and visceral practical action sequences.

Read the full review →
Vulture
17 September 2026 · festival review
80*

McKinley's Depression-era thriller about prisoners transporting gold bars through Oregon forests establishes strong physical and emotional stakes with believable camaraderie and tension from the cast led by Ethan Hawke. It singles out the atmospheric, lived-in world and survival-thriller elements as the kind of exciting period drama we don't get much anymore.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
17 September 2026 · Beatrice Loayza
70*

The critic finds the film an adrenaline-spiked adventure that doesn't fully reach the suspense of classics like Deliverance, but Hawke's arresting performance carries its testosterone-fueled escapism. The script is noted for feeling forced at times despite confidently choreographed sequences.

Read the full review →
Time Out
17 February 2026 · 3 out of 5 stars · Stephen A Russell
70*

McKinley’s Great Depression gold heist has a welcome old-fashioned ’70s vibe and charm, largely thanks to Ethan Hawke. The critic notes some overlong stretches and editing issues but praises its simple thrills and band-against-the-odds adventure feel.

Read the full review →
Los Angeles Times
18 September 2026 · Katie Walsh
65*

The critic sees the film as a 1970s throwback blending Sorcerer-style tension with indie authenticity, praising its period details, cast, and craft while noting it stages nail-biting sequences. It is faulted for opting for an oddly cheery, optimistic ending over a bolder, more despairing one.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
28 January 2026 · festival review
65*

The critic finds The Weight a conventional but mostly admirable adventure drama about gold smuggling in 1930s Oregon, anchored by Ethan Hawke's physically gruelling and persuasive lead performance. The low-budget production lacks sufficient suspense and setpieces, with some stock characters and pacing issues holding it back from greater impact.

Read the full review →
Slant Magazine
13 September 2026 · Ross McIndoe
60*

The film has an old-fashioned allure as a grubby survival thriller about prisoners smuggling gold through the wilderness, with a tactile 1930s world and clever set pieces like the rope bridge. However, its best ideas are often let down by execution, taking a too-straightforward path with few surprises or twists.

Read the full review →
Variety
27 January 2026 · festival review · Peter Debruge
60*

The critic describes it as an intermittently exciting if sometimes arduous throwback to Deliverance-era action movies, praising Hawke as a proactive problem-solver who carries the film and the score's heavy lifting. It is faulted for uneven pacing, lurching quality, and characters who lack depth beyond the lead.

Read the full review →
IndieWire
29 January 2026 · festival review · Ryan Lattanzio
30*

Padraic McKinley's action throwback is a 'Sorcerer' homage in which Hawke smuggles stolen gold through the Oregon wilderness, but the plot moves with a slow, murky trudge. It notes the resourceful inmate premise while critiquing the dragging pace and execution.

Read the full review →
The Hollywood Reporter
26 January 2026 · festival review · David Rooney
30*

The film is well-acted but murky and underpowered as a Depression-era crime drama about a gold-smuggling expedition. It praises Ethan Hawke's charismatic lead performance and some atmospheric elements but faults the lack of suspense, dimension, and dramatic power.

Read the full review →
Deadline
26 January 2026 · festival review · Pete Hammond
90*

The critic finds this a rousing, gritty Depression-era adventure that revives the spirit of classic 1970s studio pictures and should appeal to audiences in theaters. Hawke delivers a standout lead performance as a determined father driven to extremes.

Read the full review →
The Wrap
27 January 2026 · festival review · Chase Hutchinson
90*

The critic calls the film a gripping, tense Western thriller elevated by Hawke's mesmerizing, word-light lead turn as a stoic father on a perilous mission. The action sequences are well-executed and the wilderness setting adds thematic weight.

Read the full review →
The Playlist
31 January 2026 · C · Carlos Aguilar
57

The critic finds the film highly watchable but mostly by-the-numbers and predictable as a survivalist western, praising Ethan Hawke's grounded and brawny lead performance along with the energetic cinematography of the natural landscapes. They single out the derivative screenplay for complaint, noting its reliance on familiar tropes and archetypes without deeper innovation or commitment to its themes.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate