Every review in is favourable, and the praise gathers in the same places. Most critics read the film as a deadpan black comedy about revenge and equality, and find the comedy lands: the absurd is played as plain fact, and the humour has a gallows edge. Zbigniew Zamachowski’s lead performance is singled out again and again for its mix of bafflement and resourcefulness, and several reviews admire the sharp but affectionate portrait of a Warsaw turning to gangster capitalism.
The reservations are small and consistent. The recurring complaint is slightness: this is widely seen as the least weighty film of the trilogy, raw beside Blue, and a few reviewers feel the comedy and the love story sit uneasily together. The Independent thinks the female lead is underwritten; Empire finds the symbolism and moralising intrusive. The spread is narrow, with The New York Times alone treating it as a marvel rather than an agreeable minor work.
