Critics’ reviews

Toy Story 2 (1999)

11 reviews from 11 publications. Critics’ score 86: 7 positive, 1 mixed, 0 negative.

Back to our review of Toy Story 2

86
Positive
7
Mixed
1
Negative
0

Most critics regard Toy Story 2 as a sequel that matches or improves on the original, with praise clustering around its inventive script, accomplished animation and strong voice work. The reviews repeatedly connect its technical advances to its emotional reach: the toys’ fears of being forgotten give the comedy weight without crowding out the jokes. New characters and lively set-pieces also draw praise, as does the balance of entertainment for children and wit for adults.

The disagreement concerns freshness and tone rather than the strength of that emotional connection. Sight and Sound finds the sequel less fresh despite its richer understanding of the toys’ limited time with their owners. Slant Magazine offers the clearest dissent, finding the staging and direction flawed, the action short on imagination and the sweetness excessive, while still recognising its feeling for love and loss. The spread is otherwise concentrated firmly at the positive end.

Radio Times
★★★★★ · David Parkinson
100

Praises it for surpassing the predecessor and restoring credibility to family entertainment, with thrilling action for youngsters and clever in-jokes and touches for grown-ups; calls it nigh-on perfect.

Read the full review →
RogerEbert.com
24 November 1999 · ★★★★/4 · Roger Ebert
100

The critic praises the film for capturing the emotional bond between children and their toys, emphasizing themes of love, belonging, and the fear of being forgotten. It highlights the inventive storytelling, strong voice performances, and Pixar's animation as creating a profound and entertaining experience beyond typical sequels.

Read the full review →
The Guardian
4 February 2000 · Peter Bradshaw
90*

The critic calls it an upgrade and species leap in animation rather than a mere sequel, praising its technical magnificence, hyperreal visuals, and human script that surpasses earlier films like The Phantom Menace. They single out the emotional power of Jessie's song "When She Loved Me" as a standout tear-jerker alongside the witty characterisation and inventive plot.

Read the full review →
Variety
17 November 1999 · Todd McCarthy
90*

The review calls it a richer and more satisfying sequel with broadened scope, emotional depth, and boisterous humor that surpasses the original in every respect. It highlights the fresh characters, thematic poignancy around mortality, and outstanding voice work as key strengths.

Read the full review →
Empire
1 January 2000 · Caroline Westbrook
85*

The critic calls Toy Story 2 a highly superior sequel that matches the original in quality and inventiveness, with strong new characters, set-pieces and jokes. It is praised for the care taken to make it as good as the first film rather than a quick cash-in, leaving viewers wanting more.

Read the full review →
The New York Times
24 November 1999 · Janet Maslin
85*

The review celebrates the sequel's enhanced imagination and technical sophistication while maintaining the charm and wit of the original. It singles out the film's ability to blend cutting-edge animation with heartfelt storytelling about loyalty and nostalgia without sentimentality.

Read the full review →
Los Angeles Times
19 November 1999 · Kenneth Turan
80*

The critic finds the film lively and good-humored, delivering smart comedy and impressive visuals while exploring themes of mortality and identity for toys. It praises the emotional depth and inventive scenarios that make it both comic and surprisingly moving.

Read the full review →
Slant Magazine
1 October 2009 · Aaron Cutler
60*

The critic finds Toy Story 2 flawed in its staging, direction, and overly sweet tone compared to the original, with action sequences lacking imagination. However, it remains emotionally resonant through its themes of love, loss, and the bond between toys and their owner.

Read the full review →
Sight and Sound
1 March 2000 · Kim Newman

The critic praises its sophisticated, melancholy understanding of toys' brief shelf-life and emotional depth, noting effective upgrades over the first film like integrated musical numbers, while acknowledging it's less fresh.

Read the full review →
Time Out
13 March 2014 · GA

The critic finds this sequel a work of even greater wit and imagination than the first, with great gags, action and dialogue that touch the heart without sentimentality, making it wonderful for kids and adults alike.

Read the full review →
Eye for Film
19 January 2001 · Angus Wolfe Murray

The critic finds that John Lasseter's sequel matches the original technically, imaginatively and emotionally. The toys feel familiar on a second outing but the Pixar animation and heartfelt storytelling remain strong.

Read the full review →

Ordered by the weight we give each publication, then by score. Scores are normalised to 100; * means inferred from an unrated review. Summaries are ours, not quotations; follow the links for the reviews themselves. How we rate