Most critics lean towards liking it, and the praise clusters in the same places: Myers’s asides to camera, the performances of the two leads, and the sight gags and non sequiturs that arrive faster than the plot. Several credit Penelope Spheeris for keeping a loose, sketch-shaped film on track, and the more recent reviews find something smarter underneath, a comedy about friendship, music and refusing to sell out that holds up better than most films built from a television sketch.
The reservations are about length. The negative reviews say a thin sketch has been stretched and padded to feature size, with too little incident to carry it. The Guardian finds the whole thing juvenile and dated, and Time Out thinks the leads lack the charisma of Bill and Ted. The spread is wide, from 30 to 85, and it runs largely along one line: the critics writing in 1992 are cool, and those looking back decades later are warm.
