Awards
Academy Awards4 nominated
- Nominated2025Best Supporting Actor · A Complete Unknown
- Nominated2015Best Supporting Actor · Birdman
- Nominated1999Best Actor · American History X
- Nominated1997Best Supporting Actor · Primal Fear
BAFTA Film Awards1 nominated
- Nominated1997Best Actor in a Supporting Role · Primal Fear
Golden Globes1 won
- Won1996Best Supporting Actor – Motion Picture · Primal Fear
Other awards3 won · 6 nominated
- Nominated2007Independent Spirit Awards: Best Male Lead · The Painted Veil
- Nominated2003Satellite Award for Best Actor – Motion Picture: Satellite Award for Best Actor – Motion Picture · 25th Hour
- Nominated2001Satellite Award for Best Actor in a Musical or Comedy: Satellite Award for Best Actor in a Musical or Comedy · Keeping the Faith
- Nominated2000MTV Movie Award for Best Fight: MTV Movie Award for Best Fight · Fight Club
- Won1999Satellite Award for Best Actor – Motion Picture: Satellite Award for Best Actor – Motion Picture · American History X
- Nominated1997MTV Movie Award for Best Villain: MTV Movie Award for Best Villain · Primal Fear
- Won1996Boston Society of Film Critics Award for Best Supporting Actor: Boston Society of Film Critics Award for Best Supporting Actor · Everyone Says I Love You
- Won1996Los Angeles Film Critics Association Award for Best Supporting Actor: Los Angeles Film Critics Association Award for Best Supporting Actor · Everyone Says I Love You
- Nominated1996National Society of Film Critics Award for Best Supporting Actor: National Society of Film Critics Award for Best Supporting Actor · Everyone Says I Love You
Awards from Wikidata, which records wins more completely than nominations.